Ferndale Pizza Co.

Hands down the best pizza place around! When I think pizza I think Ferndale Pizza Co. Not only is there main dish incredible, but they also have Spaghetti and Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo. Both are just as amazing, the bread on the side always tastes fresh and is very fluffy. If you aren't into gluten they also offer a personal gluten-free pizza. If you aren't into pizza or pasta, well they also have a pretty good salad bar. There customer service is one of the best around, all the waiters and waitresses do an incredible job at making you feel right at home. There is this one guy there, not sure of the name, but he is always smiling and is incredibly nice. Their entire staff completely deserves whatever tip you decide to give them. Last but not least, the atmosphere. I always have a good time waiting for my food looking around at all the cool little decorations they have. This place has a lot of character. Lots of fun signs all over the walls, and out front they have beautiful Edison bulb string lights. Really adds to the energy of this place. Very warm and calming, like their food. This is the perfect place to take your significant other, friends, family for a cozy pizza night. Highly recommend Ferndale Pizza Co.

That was honestly some of the worst pizza I’ve had. Undercooked dough that had as much flavor as the roof of my mouth. So little sauce that it seemed like it was glazed with tomato soup. Toppings under the half inch of cheese. Read that sentence again: TOPPINGS UNDER. As in the ingredients that go ON TOP of the pizza are buried under cheese that, for a cow town that’s all about dairy, was not good. And even though it was 4:30 with only two other parties in the restaurant, it took over 30 minutes to come out of the kitchen. Anyone who claims to like this pizza has apparently never left Ferndale. I’ve had better pizza from a gas station. The picture says it all. Right after I took it, the pie went directly in the garbage. I wish I’d spared the cardboard box the shame of having to be the vehicle for pizza so bad that I realized I wouldn’t even want it when I was drunk and hungry later.

Wonderful staff! They were willing to make a half and half pizza for us with a white sauce on one half and tomato sauce on the other half. So many places don't allow 2 separate sauces on a pizza. LOVE IT! His and Her Pizza! TASTY pizza dough! The crust is chewy and just the right thickness... By the way, the large was way large for 2 of us! We had a small one time through the salad bar as well. This is a great pizza place! Fun atmosphere, so glad we stopped for a bite!

My grandson and I bought a 'supreme' pizza, uncooked so we could have hot, fresh pizza in Eureka. I can only recall one other place that had pizza almost as good as Ferdale Pizza Co. pizza. All the ingredients were fresh and very tasty. I'm just sad that I was visiting from San Jose otherwise I would be getting pizzas from them all the time. If you're anywhere near Ferndale and have access to an oven, take the trip and treat yourself to fantastic pizza.

I loved this place the first time I had it. I am new to the area. But the last time I got it, a day and a half ago, I got bad food poisoning and so did my bf. 54$ for food poisoning, food I can't finish and I am still in bed sick. I got chicken parm, eggplant Parm, with spaghetti and lasagna. I also got a salad. Honestly, I wish I hadn't gotten sick because their food was so good but clearly it's not up to par. The first time I ate there, I noticed one of the younger boys eating pieces of the bread that was going with my food. No gloves on either. I guess that should have been a pretty clear indicator. Anyways, if you don't take this as a warning, good luck, I hope your food comes out better than mine.